PDA

View Full Version : Chinese Woman Sues Gov't


Isabelle Warwicke
01-15-2008, 01:28 PM
A Chinese woman who was forced to have an abortion despite being nine months pregnant is suing the authorities for their actions.

Jin Yani's waters had already broken when China's abortion police came for her. They took her to a nearby abortion centre, injected her unborn baby girl and removed the body two days later.

Mrs Jin's crime was to have become pregnant by her fiance five months before she married him at the age of 20, the legal minimum.

Pregnancy outside marriage is illegal. But forced abortions are now supposed to be illegal in China.

In a blow against the state's brutally imposed one-child policy, she and her husband are claiming danmages against the authorities, saying that officials acted unlawfully.

China's higher courts have agreed to hear the plea - the first time this has happened in a case of this kind.

Yang Zhongchen, her husband, tried to prevent the abortion by wining and dining officials in Hebei province. He also agreed to pay a fine of Ģ650, but none of this prevented Changli county family planning officials arriving on Sept 7, 2000.

Mrs Jin said: "I got on my knees and begged them after they took me to the clinic and said I wanted to give birth to my daughter. I had already named her Yang Yin."

In the clinic, she was injected with a large syringe. Her husband arrived in time to witness the removal of the dead foetus with forceps two days later.

Mrs Jin lost blood, and was hospitalised for 44 days. Her husband was charged for the medicine she needed. He said that his wife is now infertile as a result of the abortion.

Mr Yang has demanded Ģ85,000 to cover medical expenses, psychological distress and Mrs Jin's inability to conceive.

At first the case got nowhere, but the regional people's court agreed to hear the couple's appeal in October. At that point, Mr Yang said that officials made contact offering him a job and free hospital treatment for his wife. But that is not enough, he said.

"They have made no mention of damages," he said while on a visit to Beijing to meet his lawyer. "We can get a job anywhere."

But the couple say they can never truly be compensated. "Our baby will never come back," Mrs Jin said. "We just hope this kind of thing will never happen again."

Goddess, I hope she wins the case.

Torra
01-15-2008, 01:56 PM
This case is highly interesting to me...I'm amazed the higher courts consented to hear it, frankly. I'd like to see how it plays into the one-child policy, and I'd like to know if she really is infertile now. If she is, that's stronger for the case, but if she ever miraculously conceives, that could be incredibly problematic for them. I hope she wins, it would do wonders for the status of women in China.

Isabelle Warwicke
01-15-2008, 02:05 PM
I think that it's interesting, as a backlash and a symptom of China's "one child rule" there is a startling dempgraphic that has been created. There will be nearly 30 million unmarried men by the year 2020 due to families choosing to keep male children. I forsee a Female Revolution in China. Can't wait.

http://www.usatoday.com/news/world/2002/06/19/china-usat.htm

surlywench
01-15-2008, 02:45 PM
I think that it's interesting, as a backlash and a symptom of China's "one child rule" there is a startling dempgraphic that has been created. There will be nearly 30 million unmarried men by the year 2020 due to families choosing to keep male children. I forsee a Female Revolution in China. Can't wait.

http://www.usatoday.com/news/world/2002/06/19/china-usat.htm

There was an article about those 30 million unmarried men being a worry to other nations as most would likely choose to join the military and thus swell the ranks to the point where China might be able to pursue "locking down" those nations around it...yeah. good times ahead. goooood times.

DoņaNina
01-15-2008, 02:47 PM
Poor lady. Reminds me of the crap that went down in North Korea, where this nurse had to perform abortions on the women who became pregnant with lovers from South Korea. Geez.

Torra
01-15-2008, 04:51 PM
I hate to say this, but I doubt she'll win. The judges will likely consider the precedent being set by this case, and it would be dangerous for their one-child rule, as well as providing lawyers with enough wiggle room to threaten their "forced abortions as a solution" action plan.